This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

The Five Questions Every Investor Asks Before They Invest

Every investor kept asking the same five questions.

A sponsor I talked with recently had a real deal, in a real market, with a real plan.

And yet every investor conversation circled back to the same place:

Have you exited a deal?

Where does the cash flow come from?

What's the NOI?

What are the operating expenses?

When do distributions start?

None of those answers lived anywhere an investor could find them. There was no NDA, no data room, and a projected IRR doing most of the talking.

So every call started from zero, and every investor quietly did the math on how much work it would take to trust them.

Here's what over a decade of raising capital has taught me about this.

Most investors who go quiet never tell you why. In my experience, it's usually because a question they asked didn't get a clean answer, fast.

So answer them before they ask. These are the five, and what a good answer looks like for each.

Question 1: Have You Actually Exited A Deal?

Question 1: Have you actually exited a deal?

This is the first question, even when nobody says it out loud.

A full cycle deal means you bought it, operated it and sold it, and your investors got their money back with a return. Refinances and recapitalizations are useful, but they don't count.

If you have full cycle exits, put them on one page: purchase price, hold period, sale price, equity multiple, and what investors actually received.

If you don't have any yet, say so plainly. Then show what you do have: the refinances, the track record of the operator you're partnering with, and how you'll protect capital if the plan takes longer than expected.

Leading with a projected IRR when you've never sold anything is one of the fastest ways to lose a sophisticated investor.

Question 2: Where Does The Cash Flow Come From?

Question 2: Where does the cash flow come from?

Investors want to see the property make money today, not just at the sale.

Show the trailing 12 months of actual income next to the pro forma. Then walk them from today's numbers to your projected numbers line by line, with the reason behind every change.

If rents go up in your model, show the comps. If occupancy improves, show exactly what has to happen for it to improve.

Question 3: What's The NOI, And Do You Believe It?

Question 3: What's the NOI, and do you believe it?

NOI is the number everything else is built on, so it's the one they'll test hardest.

Give them in-place NOI and projected NOI side by side. Then show what happens if rent growth is flat, if occupancy slips a few points, or if insurance and taxes keep climbing.

Hypothetical example: a 120-unit multifamily property with $1.2 million of in-place NOI and a business plan that takes it to $1.5 million. Show them the deal at $1.3 million too. If it still works there, say so. If it doesn't, they'll find out in diligence anyway.

Question 4: What Are The Operating Expenses, Really?

Question 4: What are the operating expenses, really?

This is where a lot of pro formas get optimistic.

In many states, property taxes reassess after a sale. Insurance has climbed fast in a lot of markets. Payroll, repairs and turnover usually cost more than the spreadsheet admits.

Break operating expenses out by line item, show the cost per unit, and compare it to the seller's actuals and to what similar properties really run.

An investor who can see you already stress-tested your expenses doesn't have to do it for you.

Question 5: When Do I Get Paid, And How?

Question 5: When do I get paid, and how?

Distributions are the question behind every other question.

Spell out the waterfall in plain English: the preferred return, when distributions start, how often they're paid, and what happens at a sale or refinance.

Then put your fees on the same page. Acquisition fee, asset management fee, disposition fee and promote. Family offices especially want transparency and clear fees.

Fees an investor has to dig for don't stay hidden...

They show up in diligence, and that's usually where the conversation ends.

Put The Answers Where They Can Find Them

The data room: put the answers where investors can find them

Answering these well on a call is good. Having them in writing is better, because investors share deals with partners, spouses and advisors who were never on your call.

The order I like: NDA, then a one-pager, then the data room, then follow-up, then meeting in person.

The data room holds every answer above: track record, trailing financials, rent roll, expense breakdown, sensitivity analysis, waterfall and fees.

When an investor opens it and finds the answer before they think to ask, the conversation changes. They stop testing you and start asking about the deal.

Go back to that sponsor for a second. Their deal wasn't the problem.

The problem was that every investor had to dig for the same five answers, one call at a time.

Write them down once. Then let the next call be about whether they want in.

The data room is one piece of a bigger setup. Here's how it fits together: what is a capital raising system.

See This Week's Latest Video On YouTube

How to Find Family Offices and Ultra Wealthy Investors Without a Warm Intro

Watch: How to Find Family Offices and Ultra Wealthy Investors Without a Warm Intro

From The Home Front

I could've just called the plumber...

But it was a teaching opportunity instead.

So I had my two boys research how to do it on YouTube, then assigned them to carry out the replacements: a new toilet and a new bathroom faucet.

My two boys replacing a toilet and a bathroom faucet

The Daily Check Size Waitlist Is Open

Capital. News. Stories. One short email a day.

Join the Daily Check Size waitlist: Capital. News. Stories.

Most sponsors hear what worked after the raise closes. The people on this list hear it while it's still happening. Join the waitlist

Educational content only. Examples are hypothetical, not financing quotes or investment recommendations. No investment is risk-free. This is not an offer to sell securities. Work with your own legal and investment advisers.